Ohio EPA's Involvement

   

Ohio EPA's Involvement in the Warren Township Hydrogen Sulfide Investigation

The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) released a health consultation on September 18, 2002, regarding the hydrogen sulfide exposure investigation conducted in Trumbull County, Ohio. ATSDR had been petitioned to evaluate whether hydrogen sulfide levels in ambient air pose an immediate health threat to the people of Warren Township. Based on available air monitoring data, ATSDR determined that "...some residents could experience some health effects, such as nausea, headaches, eye irritation, and respiratory irritation as a result of exposure to hydrogen sulfide in ambient air."

Ohio EPA recognizes the seriousness of ATSDR's conclusion and is working closely with all agencies involved in this matter. Ohio EPA's main role is to provide technical support, and primarily concerns the compliance and regulatory issues associated with any industrial facilities in question. -All issues related to health effects are best addressed by the health experts at the local health department and the Ohio Department of Health (ODH).

ATSDR's report contained six recommendations that are currently being addressed by a multi-agency committee. A complete list of the recommendations and the agency who will carry out the actions associated with each recommendation is provided in ATSDR's Public Health Action Plan. Ohio EPA is focusing its efforts on two of ATSDR's recommendations. Additional information on Ohio EPA's involvement is provided below.

ATSDR Recommendation #5

ATSDR recommended that ground water monitoring wells be installed and intermittently sampled at the perimeter of Warren Recycling, Inc.'s construction and demolition debris (C&DD) facility. The purpose of this is to evaluate whether landfill leachate is impacting aquifers used for drinking water by area residents.

Ohio EPA's Involvement

  • A possible source of the hydrogen sulfide odors is Warren Recycling, Inc.'s C&DD facility. To date, this is the only local facility regulated under Ohio's environmental laws that has been identified as a potential source of the odors. Any odors from the facility could be migrating above ground and/or below ground. The actions taken for the above recommendation will evaluate whether hydrogen sulfide is migrating from the facility through the ground water.
  • The Warren City Health Department is the local regulatory agency involved in implementing Ohio's C&DD regulations Warren. Ohio EPA's Division of Solid and Infectious Waste Management (DSIWM) provides the health department with technical assistance on C&DD regulations, including ground water monitoring issues. Warren City Health Department has already requested that Warren Recycling, Inc. install ground water monitoring wells at the landfill. Ohio EPA will assist the health department in reviewing the proposed ground water monitoring program for compliance with state regulations prior to installation of the system at the facility.

ATSDR Recommendation #6

ATSDR recommended that all major sources of hydrogen sulfide in ambient (outdoor) air be identified. Local and state officials should continue to work to reduce exposure of area residents to hydrogen sulfide gas, and to ensure that facilities identified as sources comply with these strategies to protect the health of the public.

Ohio EPA's Involvement

  • While it is possible that Warren Recycling, Inc.'s C&DD facility may be the source, it is not the only potential source of the hydrogen sulfide odors. Each possible source needs to be identified and evaluated. Ohio EPA's Division of Air Pollution Control (DAPC) is developing a list of potential hydrogen sulfide emitting sources in the area, including industrial and natural sources.
  • Ohio EPA will use sampling data and odor complaint information to investigate those potential sources whose activities are regulated under Ohio's environmental laws. At the same time, it is possible that hydrogen sulfide odors may be coming from a source that is not regulated by Ohio EPA. Ohio EPA will seek the assistance of the appropriate agencies to investigate other potential sources as necessary.
  • Ohio EPA has worked closely with local authorities to develop an odor complaint system that will immediately notify local responders of any potential health threats, so that prompt action can be taken to investigate the odors and evacuate citizens if needed. The system was also established to gather sufficient information for Ohio EPA to evaluate trends in our investigation of the odor source. The complaint system is explained in greater detail in a separate handout.

Contact Information

  • For more information regarding ATSDR's investigation report, contact Michelle Colledge or Lynn Wilder, ATSDR, at (888) 422-8737.
  • For health questions, contact Bob Frey, (614) 466-1069, or Eric Yates, (614) 995-4157, of the Ohio Department of Health.
  • For regulatory questions and technical assistance, contact Katharina Snyder, Ohio EPA-DSIWM or Joseph Loucek, Ohio EPA-DAPC, at (800) 686-6330.
  • To report an odor complaint, please refer to the contact numbers provided in the odor complaint handout.